Thursday, March 28, 2013

Week 2: Should Wikipedia be forbidden in students' social studies research?

As a Social Studies teacher, I understand why this is a hot topic. I once told students that they should not use Wikipedia because much of the information is not reliable because anyone is capable of posting to it. Now, especially with the new career and college readiness standards being implemented, I am starting to allow them to use Wikipedia. As we focus on those higher order thinking questions, I have begin teaching my students to not rely on one source. Students need to understand that in basically every aspect of life they should do their research before forming their opinion. For instance, we do current event articles and I try to make students understand that reporters, news companies, magazines, etc. often lean towards a side and by forming your opinion from one current event you may find yourself leaning too. With research, teachers can let students use whichever resources they want, but force them to use several resources so that they will have to do the research and compare sources to find which sources are most reliable. Wikipedia may be reliable or unreliable in different instances.

4 comments:

  1. Yes, I am always told not to allow wikipedia to be a source because it's not reliable! I thinks if students are doing work then they should be allowed to use any source they choose!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really liked your blog! I think that if students are actively engaged in the topic any resource they choose will be great!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with what you said about teaching students to apply higher order thinking skills when researching a topic. It is imperative students learn how to differentiate between reliable and unreliable sources of information. It is so easy for people in general to take the first answer or piece of information we find online, and assume it is correct and reliable.

    ReplyDelete